Other countries have laws condemning hate speech
Different countries have various ways to approach hate speech. Some don’t do anything at all while others are strict about it.
<
(2 of 3)
Next argument >
The Argument
Hate speech has varying consequences around the world. In the United States, hate speech is not considered illegal, but is instead considered freedom of speech.[1] In Japan, a relatively peaceful country, there are laws that condemn hate speech.[2] In the UK, although there are no specific laws against hate speech, according to the Public Order Act in 1986, no one can be discriminated against because of their identity.[3] Even though not all countries protect against hate speech, the fact that some do put laws in place should be evidence that hate speech should be illegal.
Counter arguments
Making laws against hate speech would take away the right to free speech. If no one can speak their minds about things and people that bother them, then a country’s population is being kept under too much government control.
Proponents
Premises
[P1] There are countries who protect people against hate speech.
[P2] There are laws and legislative motions that can make hate speech illegal, so it should be illegal across the globe.
Rejecting the premises
[Rejecting P2] Discrimination and hate speech are two different things. Hate speech doesn’t have the goal of preventing anyone from having basic human rights.
References
- https://clarionproject.org/where-does-the-law-stand-on-hate-speech/
- https://japantoday.com/category/features/opinions/hate-speech-in-japan
- http://www.civilrightsmovement.co.uk/faq-what-classed-hate-speech.html
In the Wild
- Internet giants could be fined up to $12 million under Austrian hate speech law
- Why is Scotland's Hate Crime Bill so controversial?
- Disinformation in a time of Covid-19: Weekly trends from South Africa
- TikTok, Israeli gov't team up to battle antisemitism, hate speech
- France Threatens Big Fines for Social Media With Hate-Speech Law